The Set List: How Did Your Broadway Favorites Miscast Themselves at the 2024 Concert?

Each year, Miscast proves to be one of the industry's favorite concert events, featuring Broadway stars performing songs from roles in which they might not be traditionally cast. The annual gala for MCC Theater was held April 15 at Hammerstein Ballroom and honored Jason Robert Brown, whose latest show The Connector recently premiered at MCC. Nicole Suazo, MCC Youth Company alum, was also honored.

Of course, you can't honor a three-time Tony-winning composer without singing a few of his tunes. So, before the the main Miscast concert began, some of Brown's past stars serenaded the audience with a few of songs from the shows they were in—but not from roles they played. It is Miscast, after all. Here's what they sang:

Andréa Burns performed "She Cries" from Songs for a New World
Hannah Cruz performed "See Yourself" from The Connector
Alex Joseph Grayson performed "You Don't Know This Man" from Parade
Ben Platt performed "I Can Do Better Than That" from The Last Five Years
Kelli O'Hara performed "Wondering" from The Bridges of Madison County
Steven Pasquale performed "Always Better" from The Bridges of Madison County

Hannah Cruz, Ben Platt, Kelli O'Hara, Steven Pasquale, Andréa Burns, and Alex Joseph Grayson Heather Gershonowitz

Following dinner, more of Broadway's best took the stage for the official Miscast program. Take a look at that set list below:

Nicholas Christopher (replacing Wayne Brady) performed "One Night Only" from Dreamgirls
Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer performed "Franklin Shepherd, Inc." from Merrily We Roll Along
Mykal Kilgore performed "Stars and the Moon" from Songs for a New World
Lauren Patten performed "One Song Glory" (on acoustic guitar) from Rent
Brian d'Arcy James performed "I Miss the Mountains" from Next to Normal
Joy Woods and Ryan Vasquez performed "Losing My Mind" from Follies
Amber Iman performed "How Glory Goes" from Floyd Collins
Ingrid Michaelson performed a "With You/What More Can I Say" mashup from Pippin/Falsettos
Vanessa Williams performed "A Lot of Livin' to Do" from Bye, Bye Birdie
Lea Salonga performed "Edelweiss" from The Sound of Music
Jinkx Monsoon performed "One Day More" from Les Misérables
Tamika Lawrence performed "From Now On" from The Greatest Showman
Gavin Creel performed a Mamma Mia! medley

The concert event will be broadcast digitally in partnership with Broadway Unlocked. The stream premieres April 29 at 7 PM or is available on demand through May 5. Tickets are available now at MCCTheater.org. See exclusive photos from the evening below.