Read the Reviews For All In: Comedy About Love By Simon Rich On Broadway

All In: Comedy About Love By Simon Rich officially opened its Broadway run at the Hudson Theatre December 22, and the reviews are in! See what critics are saying about the new show, directed by Alex Timbers and running through February 16, 2025, below.

The work comprises Simon Rich-penned stories about dating, heartbreak, and marriage, all adapted from short stories that were published in The New Yorker, whose cartoonist Emily Flake has created illustrations for the production as well. The performances also feature live music from married musical duo The Bengsons, comprising Abigail and Shaun Bengson. The pair are performing songs live on stage from The Magnetic Fields (composed by Stephin Merritt), including songs from the album 69 Love Songs, which Rich says inspired the stories that serve as the play's script.

And performing the stories are an all-star roster of Broadway and comedy favorites that will change throughout the run. John Mulaney is leading the first group alongside Fred Armisen, Renée Elise Goldsberry, and Richard Kind. Jill Abramovitz and Ben Steinfeld are serving as standbys. Goldsberry's run continues through December 30, and Kind's will continue through January 12, 2025.

Read the reviews below.

Culture Sauce (Thom Geier)

The Daily Beast (Tim Teeman)

Deadline (Greg Evans)

New York Magazine/Vulture (Sara Holdren)*

New York Post (Johnny Oleksinski)

New York Stage Review (David Finkle, Frank Scheck)

New York Sun (Elysa Gardner)

New York Theatre Guide (Caroline Cao)

The New York Times (Elisabeth Vincentelli)*

TheaterMania (Pete Hempstead)

TimeOut NY (Adam Feldman)

Variety (Frank Rizzo)

*This review may require creating a free account or a paid subscription.

Playbill will continue to update this list as reviews come in.

Chloe Fineman is joining January 2, 2025, and performing through January 12. Lin-Manuel Miranda will succeed Mulaney to lead the cast for the final five weeks, January 14-February 16, 2025. Joining him will be Aidy Bryant and Nick Kroll through February 2, and Andrew Rannells through January 26. Jimmy Fallon will join January 28 and perform through February 2, with David Cross performing February 4-9 and Sweeney Todd star and Tony winner Annaleigh Ashford and SNL alum Tim Meadows performing February 4-16. Hank Azaria will perform February 11-16. Casting is by Taylor Williams.

The production features scenic design by David Korins, lighting design by Jake DeGroot, costume design by Jennifer Moeller, sound design by Peter Hylenski, and video design by Lucy MacKinnon. Kris Kukul is music supervisor, and Scott Rowen serves as production stage manager.

Seaview and Lorne Michaels are producing with New Yorker Studios. Micah Frank and Caroline Maroney are producing for Michaels' Broadway Video, with Wagner Johnson Productions serving as general manager.

Visit AllInBroadway.com.